EcoTourismHub
Page: Orang Utan Reserve in the Klang Valley

Ecotourism Hub
   Eco Means of Travel
   KLIA-Leading in Eco-Standards
   KLIA-Next Generation Hub
   KKIA domestic hub
   Benchmark for National Parks
   What Ecotourism should be
Ecotourism Destinations | Malaysia
   Borneo Island | Ecotourism
   Sabah
   Imbak Canyon Conservation
   Colonial-styled Passenger Train
   Rhino Saved in dramatic rescue
   Climb Mt Kinabalu
   Challenges of scaling Mt Kinabalu
   Been there, done that
   Mt Kinabalu Climbathon
   Sepilok Orang Utan Sanctuary
   Sandakan's Many Charm
   Coral Reef in Semporna
   Sipadan Island
   Dive Permit at Sipadan
   Scuba Diving
   Best Diving Spots
   Protecting Sipadan
   Mabul Island
   Semporna kidnap
   Pom Pom Island
   Rare Whale
   The Finest Forests
   Shark Fin Ban
   Casino stops serving Shark fin
   Airline joins Shark fin ban
   Kinabalu Park World Heritage
   Sarawak
   A Memorable Visit to Bako
   Semenggoh Wildlife Centre
   Birding Havens in Sarawak
   Segon Cave and Bung Brunggu
   Borneo Convention Centre
   Biodiversity | Sarawak
   155,000ha allowed
   Singer Dayang to Help Orang Utans
   Ancient Croc Effigies
   Potential Ecotourism Icon
   Peninsular Malaysia | Ecotourism
   Taman Negara
   Living off the forest’s bounty
   350kg Tapir
   Endau Rompin National Park
   Endau-Rompin Location Map
   Kenyir Lake
   Kenyir Lake Triathlon
   Kenyir Lake DFZ
   Rebirth of Kenyir Lake
   Frasers Hill
   Royal Belum
   Leaders In Destinations
   Rakan Royal Belum
   Save Temenggor
   Lessons in the Forest
   Cameron Highlands
   Looking for the Silk King
   New Route
   Sepetang Serenade
   Turtle Sanctuary Site in Kemaman
   Heritage Sites Malaysia
   Lenggong Valley
   George Town and Malacca Heritage Sites
   Kinabalu Park Heritage Site
   Mulu Cave Geopark
   Danum Valley
   Maliau Basin
   Bid for Unesco listing
   Valley of Heritage
   Ramsar sites | Malaysia
   Ramsar sites in Sarawak
   Events and Festivals Malaysia
   Most Searched Travel Spots 2011
   Indigenous Malaysian Tribes
   Indigenous Peninsular Malaysia
   Danawan Island home to Sea Gypsies
Costa Rica
   Retire Here, Not There: Costa Rica
   Costa Rica's Unspoiled Coast
Ecotourism News
   Open Zoo
   Rainforest Rock Festival
   Great Wall in Gopeng
   WTC2010
   Belaga braces for tourism boom
   Tourism drops
   Palazzo Park
   Permaculture
   Rainforest World Music Festival
   WEC2010
   Focus on eco-tourism
   Kuala Gandah Elephant Centre
   Ecotourism Spotlight Award
   Tourism News
   Art Tourism Hub
   Shopping Hub
   Art Tourism
Forest Reserve
   2010 Year of Biodiversity
   The Belum Forest Reserve
   Pulau Banding Rainforest Research Centre
   Matang Mangrove Forest Reserve
   Plant Mangrove Saplings in Port Dickson
   FRIM’s first research station
   FRIM declared heritage site
   FRIM PHOTO CONTEST
   Forest Reserve News
   South Peat Swamp Forest
   Forest Reserve to grow Oil Palm
   Save the Rain Forest
   Demystifying Forensic Forestry
   Forest Reserve in Pangkor
   Forest Research Centre - Sabah
   Forest reserve gazetted in Puchong
   Rape of Lenggong forest reserve
   Development project in Forest Reserve
   FruitPlast
   SAFE Project
   SEARRP
   Saving Temenggor
   Selangor Peat Swamp
   Vanishing wetlands
   Before it is Too Late
   Tree Cover-up
   Forests to Tree Farms
   Forest by the Coast
Green
   IGEM
   The Green Initiatives
   Ecologic Label
   Rebuilding the Green Concept
   Sabah Intensifies Green Effort
   Going Google can mean Going Green
   City of Kyoto from Car-Centric to Walking City
   Turning Consumers Green
   Penang mulling over No-car Zone
   3Rs among Malaysians
   Independent Power Producer
   Roof-top Secret Garden
   Bamboo
   Population and Food
   Never Drink From Plastic
Water
   Water Footprint
   Think water conservation
   Bakun Dam
   Turning to Eco-tourism
   Bengoh Dam
   Water Concern
   Beach
   Tap Water
   Water Worries 1
   Mini-hydro Plant
   Mekong River
   Mekong News
   Water Challenge
   Looming Water Crisis
Sustainable Food Source
   Eating Insects
   U.N. Urges Eating Insects
   Insects may be the answer
   Eat Insects
   Meat is Not Green
   Health Benefits of Eating Less Meat
   Vegetarian Athletes
   Catherine Johnson, Vegan Cyclist
   Vegan Athlete of the Year 2013
   Totally Vegetarian
   Veganism and the Environment
   Mongolia Nomads
   Antibiotics in Feed
   Butter is back
Wildlife Malaysia
   Carcasses of Tigers, Leopards from Malaysia
   Malayan Tiger
   Tiger spotted on road
   Save the Tiger
   Rare Photo
   Tracing Malaysia's Tigers
   A New Hope For Malayan Tigers
   The Conservation Of Tigers
   Why Tigers Matter
   Tiger Ambassador
   White Tiger Cubs
   Siberian tiger
   Natural Habitat for Tigers
   King of the Jungle
   Permits for Zoo
   Rainbow Toad
   Orang Utan
   Leave orang utan alone
   Orang Utans
   Save Orang Utans
   Orang Utan Island
   Orang Utan Reserve in the Klang Valley
   Fireflies
   Fireflies Sanctuary gazetted
   Firefly Festival Taiping
   Crocodile Farm
   Marine Ecosystem
   Semporna marine life
   Shark
   Shark Sanctuaries
   Drop in Shark Catch
   No to Shark Fin Soup
   Stop Selling Shark Fin
   Dolphins in Port Klang
   Golden Arowana
   Symbol of Prosperity
   The Unsung Heroes
   Bees
   Save Bees From Extinction
   When Bee Stop Making Honey
   Honeybees need Help
   Help our Disappearing Bees
   Bringing back Honeybees
   Ladybird
   Dung Beetle
   Ants
   Earthworms
   Frog
   Hornbill
   Elephant
   Wild elephant
   Uneasy feeling
   Sea Anemone
   Dolphin
   Human-wildlife Conflict
   Perhilitan sets Trap for Panther
   Wildlife Act
   Illegal Wildlife Traders
   Rafflesia and Conservation Efforts
   new Rafflesia species found
   Cengal Besar
   Migratory Birds
Climate Change
   New directions for the UN
   Canada withdrawing from Kyoto
   Haze

January 18, 2011

Do we really need an orang utan reserve in the Klang Valley?

By TAN CHENG LI
star2green@thestar.com.my

How far will having another orang utan sanctuary, this time in the Klang Valley, go in saving the endangered species?

IT IS yet another case of the tom yam syndrome: “Orang utan sanctuaries in Sepilok, Sabah, and Semenggoh, Sarawak, have done very well in drawing the crowds. Hey, let’s do the same over in Peninsular Malaysia. Let’s set up an orang utan sanctuary right in the Klang Valley, so tourists need not travel all the way to Sabah and Sarawak to view the rare red apes. Never mind that there is already such an orang utan park at Bukit Merah Laketown Resort near Taiping, Perak. And never mind that the primate died out in the peninsula thousands of years ago. The Klang Valley wants its very own orang utan sanctuary.”

But leading orang utan scientists in the country and conservation groups are not at all happy with the idea. The plan is ill-conceived and lacks ecological reasoning, they argue.

Numerous questions have been raised: Why would we need another orang utan park when there is already the Orang Utan Island at Bukit Merah? Can the orang utans survive in peninsular forests? Won’t it drain already limited resources? Will this sanctuary serve any conservation purpose or is it merely a tourism product? Will wild orang utans have to be translocated from Sabah or Sarawak?

http://thestar.com.my/archives/2011/1/18/lifefocus/f_2orangutan.jpg On display: Endangered red apes at Bukit Merah Orang Utan Island in Perak. A proposal to set up a sanctuary for the species in the Klang Valley has drawn criticisms from the conservation fraternity. – Pics by CHOU K.S.

Talk about the sanctuary surfaced a year ago, when Deputy Tourism Minister Datuk Dr James Mamit said the Prime Minister had mooted the idea and the park would be set up within the Forest Research Institute of Malaysia (FRIM) in Kepong, Kuala Lumpur. But FRIM officials denied such a plan.

All was quiet until late last year, when news reports quoting Mamit said that the sanctuary will be in either the Kanching or Ulu Gombak forest reserves in Selangor. The proposal remains sketchy and no information has been forthcoming from the ministry.

Scientists are sceptical and wary of the plan.

Dr Benoit Goossens who has worked on orang utans for 13 years in the area of population genetics and conservation, describes the idea of releasing orang utans into the wilds of Peninsular Malaysia as “totally irresponsible”.

“You’re transferring them to an environment where they disappeared from thousands of years ago. They’re adapted to Borneon and Sumatran forests and would not be able to cope in Peninsular Malaysia forests where there are different parasites and diseases,” says the adviser to Sabah Wildlife Department and director of Danau Girang Field Centre in Kinabatangan.

http://thestar.com.my/archives/2011/1/18/lifefocus/f_2park.jpg Training ground: Captive-born orang utans learn basic skills such as climbing and building nests at this man-made exercise yard at Bukit Merah Orang Utan Island .

“We have reintroduced species into the wild but this was for species which disappeared decades, not thousands, of years ago. I guarantee that it will be a failure. You will be sending orang utans to their deaths. We don’t even know which species occurred in the peninsula in the past. So releasing them into the wild is scientifically irresponsible,” he says.

Studies on what food is available in the forest for the orang utan and potential threats to their survival must be done prior to any releases, he adds.

He also does not support the idea of an orang utan sanctuary for tourists as it would duplicate existing facilities. “I don’t see the point of putting orang utans in yet another semi-captive environment in Peninsular Malaysia. There are already captive orang utans in zoos.”

Like many others, he believes money will be better spent if used to protect wild orang utans in Sabah and Sarawak rather than by setting up a sanctuary in the peninsula. “There is no conservation role in such parks. If you want to give a conservation message, then people should be encouraged to go to Borneo or Sumatra to see orang utans in their natural habitat.”

Reintroduction risks

Veterinarian Dr Marc Ancrenaz, director of Kinabatangan Orang Utan Conservation Programme in Sabah, too, disagrees with the release of orang utans into Peninsular Malaysia forests chiefly because the primate no longer exists in the wild there. The scientific adviser to Sabah Wildlife Department who has studied orang utans for the past 15 years, says orang utans are believed to have died out in the peninsula because of climatic changes and hunting.

He says that under International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) guidelines, reintroduction of species should be considered only if no other alternatives exist to save the species.

“But there are still wild orang utans in Sabah and Sarawak. So the plan to release orang utans will not be supported by IUCN. The priority should be to protect Sabah and Sarawak populations before reintroducing. We don’t know what disease the orang utans might bring to the new environment and there is also a risk of orang utans dying and not adapting. That’s why scientists are against the introduction of orang utans into Peninsular Malaysia. It is always difficult to release captive animals into the wild. Most will die.”

Ancrenaz asserts that a sanctuary, though useful for promoting public awareness, does little for conservation.

“Conservation is about protecting wild populations. We have to decide which is more important ... to secure wild populations or to use the species for tourism. The priority should be protecting wild populations, which can also be used for tourism.”

Duplicating efforts

S.M. Mohd Idris, president of Sahabat Alam Malaysia, sees the proposed project as the development of another tourist attraction and “has no relevance to conservation or to the well-being of the orang utan.”

“Tourism is not a panacea for orang utan conservation or revenue generation. We do not need another primate sanctuary where animals are treated like humans and hand-raised in nappies in a nursery.”

Rather than creating a new reserve, Idris urges the Government to develop management plans to ensure the long-term survival of the primate, particularly to address conversion of forest habitats to plantations.

He says the orang utans, if released into the forests, might adversely impact local ecosystems and species.

He says translocation would only be appropriate if the natural range of the orang utans in Borneo and Sumatra can no longer support the species or the species has been extirpated there.

“A thorough environmental impact study needs to be conducted to evaluate possible negative consequences of such relocation, involving wildlife managers, veterinarians, wildlife officials, primatologists and orang utan scientists and the result of the report must be made public,” says Idris.

The Malaysian Nature Society (MNS), too, fails to see the need for a new sanctuary, seeing that such facilities already exist and aid in ex situ conservation (outside of their natural habitat) of the species.

“Resources should be channelled to these places and not to another sanctuary, especially not to one that is outside the primate’s natural distribution,” says Yeap Chin Aik, MNS conservation department head. “Why not improve the orang utan conservation work and exhibit at Zoo Negara following modern zoological trends and concepts?”

He says no orang utans should be released into Peninsular Malaysia forests unless it is scientifically established that the species will have no negative impact on any of the other arboreal species of the Malaysian forest.

“Orang utan habitats are shrinking and being degraded by various land uses. If we have the funds, it’s better to channel it into orang utan habitat protection in East Malaysia, rather than to set up more man-made sanctuaries and rescue centres, especially those with misguided or no clear purposes,” says Yeap.

Should the sanctuary be set up, where will the apes come from? Authorities in Sabah and Sarawak have said they will not supply orang utans for the purpose of tourism. So chances are that the primates will have to be the captive-breds in existing peninsular zoos.

Another zoo?

Nobody knows for sure what form the sanctuary will take. But if tourism is the key driving force, it is unlikely that the orang utans will be left to roam freely in a large forest; they would then remain hidden and unseen.

In order to draw tourists, the sanctuary will surely have to be a semi-captive one so that the orang utans remain within sight of tourists and there will be scheduled feeding times (again for the benefit of tourists).

So however you call it – an orang utan sanctuary, park or reserve – the fact remains that the facility might well end up as just another zoo where the red apes are held captive and periodically released for public viewing, albeit in a larger and forested environment. Is this the kind of orang utan reserve to promote?

And rather than duplicating ongoing – and world-renowned – orang utan conservation efforts in Sabah and Sarawak, shouldn’t we instead concentrate on actual conservation work to preserve species found in the peninsula and which are facing graver threats, such as the Sumatran rhinoceros and Malayan tiger?


Ecotourism Hub
Ecotourism Destinations | Malaysia
Ecotourism News
Green
Wildlife Malaysia
Glossary Ecotourism
Contact Ecotourismhub.com